Tue. Sep 9th, 2025

Beyond the Three-Peat: Club America’s Unexpected Struggle and the Atlas Opportunity

In the pantheon of Liga MX, few names resonate with the weight of expectation quite like Club America. A club that etched its name into history by becoming the first Mexican side to three-peat in the Apertura/Clausura era in December 2024. Yet, a mere whisper of “struggle” now hangs over Coapa, an almost ironic assessment for a team currently sitting fourth in the league table, just a single point off the summit. For Club America, however, proximity to the top is not enough; only outright dominance will quell the critics.

The Burden of Unparalleled Success

The recent three-peat was a monumental achievement, a testament to sustained excellence. But with such glory comes an insatiable demand for more. This season, despite their respectable league position, America`s campaign has felt somewhat off-key. Missing out on the prestigious Club World Cup after a playoff loss to Los Angeles FC, coupled with a premature exit from the Leagues Cup group stage, has created a narrative of underperformance, amplified by the club`s own sky-high standards. It`s a unique predicament: how can a team be “struggling” when it`s so close to first place? The answer lies in the DNA of Club America – anything less than perfection is a deviation from the norm.

The Attacking Conundrum: Talented Forwards, Few Goals

A key area of concern for manager Andre Jardine has been the team`s attacking output. Despite boasting a roster brimming with offensive talent, Club America has managed a paltry nine goals in 11 league games this season, averaging a mere 0.8 goals per contest. This statistic is particularly vexing given the creative potential within their ranks.

  • Alex Zendejas: The American winger, typically a reliable source of goals with 43 in 163 appearances for the club, has found the net only once this season, on matchday one against Juarez. His subsequent drought, despite the added motivation of impressing national team selectors for a World Cup spot, has been conspicuous.
  • Brian Rodriguez: The left winger is in a similar predicament, having failed to score in three consecutive league games.
  • Eric Sanchez: While midfielder Eric Sanchez has delivered commendable performances, the reliance on him highlights a broader issue: the attack feels one-dimensional, predictable, and lacking the clinical edge expected from such a star-studded lineup.

This offensive stagnation has fueled the perception of a team not living up to its potential, placing immense pressure on Jardine to unlock their scoring prowess.

Atlas: A Timely Opportunity for Offensive Revival

Enter Atlas, Club America`s next opponent. For America, this match against their Guadalajara counterparts couldn`t come at a more opportune moment. Atlas has been in a defensive freefall, conceding three or more goals in four consecutive games. Their porous backline offers what appears to be a prime opportunity for America`s struggling forwards to rediscover their scoring touch and, crucially, their confidence.

If Zendejas, Rodriguez, and their attacking compatriots cannot find the back of the net against one of Liga MX`s most vulnerable defenses, questions about the team`s systemic issues, rather than just individual form, will undoubtedly intensify. This isn`t just a regular league match; it`s a litmus test for Club America`s identity and their capacity to adapt under pressure.

The Manager`s Challenge and the Road Ahead

For Andre Jardine, the stakes are undeniably high. Winning a trophy this season is not merely a goal; it`s an expectation that defines his tenure. The perception of “struggle,” even when within touching distance of first place, underscores the relentless scrutiny that comes with managing Club America. A decisive victory, particularly one showcasing a revitalized attack, could provide the much-needed impetus to turn their season around and reaffirm their status as the league`s perennial powerhouse.

The narrative of Club America`s season is still being written. Will they succumb to the weight of their own legacy, or will the match against Atlas serve as the catalyst for a triumphant redemption arc? Mexican football demands drama, and Club America, whether by design or circumstance, is once again at the heart of it.

By Jasper Hawthorne

Jasper Hawthorne is a 34-year-old sports journalist based in Bristol. With over a decade of experience covering various sporting events, he specializes in rugby and cricket analysis. Starting his career as a local newspaper reporter, Jasper has built a reputation for his insightful post-match commentary and athlete interviews.

Related Post